Peculiarities of protection of private rights by non-jurisdiction methods of settlement of legal disputes (conflicts)

Issue: № 6/1, 2021

Doi: https://doi.org/10.37634/efp.2021.6(1).5

Introduction. Adoption of new laws of civil and substantive law, the novelty of legal relations governed by the rules of these laws, the complexity of civil conflicts arising from these legal relations, require a high level of legal protection, compliance with the rule of law by all members of society. Only the law allows interested parties to choose the form of protection. This form can be traditional – jurisdictional (provides for the establishment of a body and procedure for the protection of violated rights), and non-jurisdictional (but certainly allowed by law), which may resort to interested parties. obstacle to the exercise of the right. Resolution of legal conflicts is possible not only through a jurisdictional form of protection. A non-jurisdictional form of protection of civil rights is the independent protection of a person of his violated rights. That is, the person does not apply to the competent state authorities. In fact, it is the commission of actual actions aimed at protecting and securing their personal property and other non-property rights. The purpose of the paper is a thorough study of models of non-jurisdictional protection of property rights in the system of protection of civil rights by analyzing the theoretical and practical aspects of using alternative methods of protection of private rights in general and mediation. Result. It is determined that the non-jurisdictional form of protection of civil rights is the actions of citizens and organizations aimed at protecting their own civil rights, freedoms, and legally protected interests. It is noted that these actions are carried out and implemented by eligible entities independently, without seeking legal assistance from government agencies and structures, as well as officials. It is determined that the mechanism of legal protection is implemented in non-jurisdictional ways in the field of legal regulation when it is necessary to overcome and eliminate obstacles that arise in the exercise of rights and legitimate interests of the subject of law, in other words – to quickly protect (ensure) legal status. It is determined that in international practice, namely in European countries, the basis of non-jurisdictional protection of property rights is mainly in the use of negotiation and mediation procedures. Non-jurisdictional form, which is usually local in nature, is achieved as a result of actual actions, occurs not in jurisdictional or procedural forms, but within the protected substantive legal relations, which are the subjects of such legal relations (usually imply The main difference between jurisdictional and non-jurisdictional forms of protection of rights is that the protection of rights in jurisdictional form is carried out by the competent state and public authorities with each of them a certain procedural order of activity, while protection in a non-jurisdictional form takes place within the framework of a substantive legal relationship and is carried out by the parties themselves in the legal relationship. Conclusion. The study proves that in Ukraine, priority should be given to the development of various forms of out-of-court dispute resolution. The basis for this should be the legislative consolidation of out-of-court settlement of civil disputes as one of the basic principles of protection of violated private rights (of course, without revoking or replacing the right to judicial protection). Non-jurisdictional methods of protection of private rights are defined in the legislation of Ukraine and can be used due to the dispositive nature of the civil law method of regulation. However, this is insufficient, as participants in civil legal relations in case of violation of their rights are primarily confronted in the law with a defined right to judicial protection of violated rights, and often consider the court as the only possible form of protection.

Keywords : non-jurisdictional form of protection of civil rights, settlement of disputes (conflicts), extrajudicial procedures for protection of private rights

References:

1. Civil law: textbook / ed. S.S. Alekseev. Moscow: Velbi, 2006. P. 357. (in Russian).

2. Dzera O.V. Contract law of Ukraine. General part: textbook. allowance / ed. О.В. Dzera. Kyiv: Yurinkom Inter, 2008. P. 75 (in Ukrainian).

3. Sklovskiy K.I. Property in civil law. Moscow: Delo, 2002. P. 82. (in Russian).

4. Some aspects of notarial protection of private property of foreigners in Ukraine. Scientific Bulletin of the International Humanities University. Series: Jurisprudence. 2014. Vol. 11 (2). P. 25. (in Ukrainian).

5. Dzhun V.V. On the question of the obligation to apply restitution in case of invalidity of the agreement / Bulletin of Commercial Justice, 2002. № 4. P. 165. (in Ukrainian).

6. Pidlubna T.M. The right to protection of civil rights and interests: author's ref. dis. … PD in law: 12.00.03 / Kyiv, 2009. 20 p. (in Ukrainian).

7. Mykhalskyi Yu. Institute of Mediation in Ukraine and Abroad. Yurydychna Gazeta. 2011. February 1. № 5 (270). (in Ukrainian).

8. Decree of the President of Ukraine 31231/2021. On the Strategy for the Development of the Justice and Constitutional Judiciary for 2021-2023. URL: https://www.president.gov.ua/ documents/2312021-39137 (in Ukrainian).

9. Analytical report on the introduction of adjudication mediation in 4 pilot courts of Ukraine. Kyiv: Ukrainian Center for Understanding, 2010. (in Ukrainian).

Download paper